One rap on Obama that keeps coming back is that he is too poetic. I suppose that is supposed to conjure images of what the country might look like if run by Gregory Corso or something but it still seems like an odd criticism. “Oh, he’s too eloquent!” After seventy-seven years of Bush aren’t we due for some eloquence?
The real message of Hillary’s line — “You speak in poetry but you govern in prose!” — is: beware the sliver-tongued devil! I think the male-female split over Obama-Clinton (made all the clearer as the results of Tuesday’s primaries are parsed) is very telling. A lot of hard-working women relate to Hillary and think of her as one of them. She’s been paying dues for years, working her fingers to the bone while her faithless husband (a sliver-tongued devil if there ever was one) fluttered about making a mess of things, and making time with the help while he was at it.
Women in business have seen this pattern: they spent nights and weekends cranking out spread sheets and doing due diligence and into the Monday morning meeting comes some Johnny (and he’s always a Johnny) come lately. He’s slick, he’s handsome, he can charm the pants off a meter maid and he may not be up to the minute on the latest data, he sees the Big Picture. He’s an inspiration guy, here to give the team a big lift, and Suzy, maybe you can help him with some of your research?
Burns their biscuits, and rightfully so. But I don’t think Obama is that guy. First, he’s been a hard working legislator, eight years in the state legislature in Illinois and then two in the US Senate, and before that a community organizer is Chicago, in parts of the community no one wanted to touch, let alone organize. Secondly, now’s the time. As he says invoking the inexperienced JFK, history won’t wait. I honestly believe that HRC can’t beat McCain — too much baggage, too many negatives, not the least of which comes with old silver-tongue himself. The GOP will hit Obama with the inexperience charge but I believe that the national nausea over the old fights is not to be underestimated. Fresh and optimistic might just trump raging, war-mongering paranoia.
And thirdly, poetry has a time-honored place in politics. When the two converge, movements are born. People are stirred by words to action, sometimes even sacrifice — a concept that Obama (unlike our president) is not afraid to invoke. What was Kennedy’s inaugural address if not poetry? You may not think much of his legacy or accomplishments in his too-brief time in office, but the poetry got a lot of people to think about what they could do for their country, instead of vice versa, some for the very first time. What was the “I Have A Dream” speech? The Sermon on the Mount?
Not that I pretend to know who Jesus would have voted for. Chances are he would have said, “Vote Ceasar, and move on.” But let’s stop dissing the healing, and moving, power of poetry in politics. As a good friend of Corso’s said, singing his own paean to America, “I’m putting my queer shoulder to the wheel.”