Things have been moving way too fast and I’ve been way too busy to say anything intelligent about the events in Egypt — it’s like commenting on fireworks as they are going off. Though Twitter and Facebook have proved more than mere tools of commentary for those in the actual revolution. They have provided tools for the revolution itself, probably not what Mark Zuckerberg had in mind.
The arguments of Malcolm Gladwell and the Net Delusion’s Evgeny Morozov — that the very social-network tools that were credited for spreading dissent in Iran and China have or will become tools of repression and worse in some of those same places — seem a little beside the point now. Behind such skepticism, as healthy as it is, seems to be a kind of deep human cynicism — all the more surprising in Gladwell who has made a fortune promoting the idea of tipping points and connectors. I guess it’s okay if they’re his tipping points and connectors...
This is one those cases where the medium really is the message — or at least a value-neutral component of the message. Complaining about its use or potential misuse seems almost silly, like blaming the hammer after it’s been used in a fight instead of for building (or vice versa). The suspicion about the role the internet has and will play in the pursuit of freedom strikes me as no better than the suspicion any number of people grousing the wake of Mubarak’s overthrow (from the Tea Party paranoids to the Israelis to the right-wing think tankers) have about democracy.
Democracy is one of those open-source platforms — not owned by us, or the French, or the ancient Greeks — that needs to be used to be improved. If we don’t like the outcome of what a true democratic movement brings (and yes, I am well aware of the potential for the military barring any real reform in Egypt), we don’t really like democracy. It’s not about our interests, stupid. And the fact that we try and make it so explains why we, as a nation, are so hated in many parts of the world.
As a co-worker of mine said, watching the angry demonstrators torch the Egyptian flag the night Mubarak at first refused to step down, “Isn’t it nice to see them burn somebody else’s flag for a change?”